Skip to content

Returns & Exchanges Accepted Within 30 Days

Free Shipping, Re-sizing & Certification

Returns & Exchanges Accepted Within 30 Days

Free Shipping, Re-sizing & Certification

Simulated Vs. Lab Grown Diamonds What Exactly Are Simulated Diamonds

Simulated Vs. Lab Grown Diamonds: What Exactly Are Simulated Diamonds?

Let’s start with something many people get wrong. Walk into any jewelry store, and you’ll likely hear the terms “simulated diamonds” and “lab-grown diamonds” used interchangeably. It’s easy to see why both sound modern, shiny, and sparkly. But here’s the catch: they’re not the same thing at all. One is a diamond in every sense of the word, just made in a lab instead of dug out of the earth.

The confusion runs deep, and it’s not just limited to casual shoppers. Even some jewelers mix up the terms or use them loosely. This matters because what you think you’re buying might not be what you’re getting. And when it comes to spending your hard-earned money on something as important as a piece of jewelry, clarity is key. Understanding the differences between simulated diamonds, lab-grown diamonds, and natural diamonds will help you make smarter decisions that align with your budget, values, and expectations.

What Are Simulated Diamonds?

So, what exactly are simulated diamonds? To put it simply, these are gemstones designed to look like diamonds but aren’t diamonds in terms of their chemical makeup or physical properties. Think of them as the understudies in a play they’re there to mimic the real star, but they’re not the same person.

Common Types of Diamond Simulants

Cubic Zirconia (CZ)

Cubic Zirconia is probably the most well-known diamond simulant. It’s made from zirconium dioxide and is crafted to resemble the brilliance and fire of a diamond. CZ is affordable, widely available, and often used in costume jewelry. However, it’s softer than a diamond, which means it can scratch more easily. Over time, it may also lose some of its sparkle due to surface wear.

Moissanite

Moissanite is another popular simulant, but it’s a bit different from CZ. Originally discovered in a meteor crater, Moissanite is now mostly made in labs. Its composition includes silicon carbide, which gives it unique optical properties. Moissanite has more “fire” than a diamond, meaning it produces more colorful flashes of light. While it’s harder than CZ, it still doesn’t match the hardness of a diamond. Many people love Moissanite for its affordability and ethical sourcing, but it’s not a diamond substitute in the strictest sense.

Glass

Believe it or not, glass has been used as a diamond simulant for centuries. It’s inexpensive and can be cut to mimic the appearance of a diamond. However, glass is far too soft and fragile to be practical for everyday wear. It scratches easily and lacks the brilliance and durability of real diamonds.

Visual Characteristics of Simulants Vs. Real Diamonds

At first glance, simulants can fool the untrained eye. They’re cut and polished to imitate the sparkle of a diamond. But under closer inspection, differences become clear. For example, Moissanite tends to show more rainbow flashes, while CZ can appear slightly cloudy over time. Real diamonds, on the other hand, have a unique combination of brilliance, fire, and scintillation that’s hard to replicate fully.

What Are Lab Grown Diamonds?

Now let’s talk about lab grown diamonds. These are actual diamonds. They’re not imitations or substitutes—they’re chemically, physically, and optically identical to natural diamonds. The only difference is where they come from.

Creation Methods

High-Pressure High Temperature (HPHT) Process

This method mimics the conditions deep within the earth where natural diamonds form. A small diamond seed is placed in carbon and subjected to extreme heat and pressure, causing the carbon atoms to crystallize around the seed. The result is a diamond that’s indistinguishable from one mined from the ground.

Chemical Vapor Deposition (CVD) Process

In this process, a diamond seed is placed in a chamber filled with carbon-rich gas. Using lasers and high temperatures, the gas breaks down, and carbon atoms bond to the seed layer by layer. CVD diamonds tend to grow more slowly but are equally genuine.

Timeline for Production

Creating a lab grown diamond takes anywhere from two weeks to two months, depending on the size and quality desired. Compare that to millions of years for natural diamonds, and you can see why lab-grown options are appealing.

Certification and Grading

Just like natural diamonds, lab-grown diamonds are graded using the 4 Cs: carat, cut, color, and clarity. Reputable labs like GIA or IGI issue certificates to verify their quality and authenticity. This ensures you’re getting what you pay for.

Key Differences Between Simulants and Lab-Grown Diamonds

Chemical Composition

Simulants like CZ and Moissanite have completely different compositions compared to diamonds. A diamond whether natural or lab-grown—is pure carbon arranged in a crystal lattice. Simulants don’t share this structure, which affects their performance.

Physical Properties

Hardness

On the Mohs scale of mineral hardness, diamonds rank a perfect 10. Moissanite comes in at 9.25, while CZ is around 8.5. Glass? Only a 5.5. This means simulants are much more prone to scratching and damage.

Durability and Longevity

Lab grown diamonds are as durable as natural ones, making them ideal for everyday wear. Simulants, especially softer ones like CZ, may need frequent replacement if worn regularly.

Optical Characteristics

Real diamonds reflect light in a way that’s difficult to replicate. Simulants often show more dispersion (rainbow effects) or less brilliance, giving away their true identity.

Professional Identification Methods

Jewelers use tools like microscopes, refractometers, and thermal conductivity testers to distinguish between simulants and real diamonds. These methods ensure accuracy when verifying a stone’s authenticity.

To make things clearer, let’s break down the main differences in a simple table format. This will help you quickly compare simulants (like Cubic Zirconia and Moissanite) with lab-grown diamonds across several important categories.

Category Simulants (e.g., CZ, Moissanite) Lab-Grown Diamonds
Chemical Composition Not pure carbon; varies by material (e.g., zirconium dioxide for CZ, silicon carbide for Moissanite). Pure carbon, identical to natural diamonds.
Hardness (Mohs Scale) Softer: CZ (8.5), Moissanite (9.25), Glass (~5.5). Hardest material: 10, same as natural diamonds.
Durability Prone to scratches and wear over time. Extremely durable, suitable for everyday wear.
Optical Properties May show more "fire" or rainbow effects (Moissanite). Can lose brilliance over time (CZ). Matches natural diamond brilliance and light performance.
Cost Very affordable: $20-$800 depending on size and type. More expensive than simulants but cheaper than natural diamonds (30-40% less).
Resale Value Virtually no resale value. Limited resale value, though higher than simulants.
Ethical Sourcing No mining is involved, but not chemically identical to diamonds. No mining is required, eco-friendly alternative to mined diamonds.
Certification Rarely certified; often sold without detailed grading. Certified by reputable labs (e.g., GIA, IGI) like natural diamonds.

Pricing and Value Comparison

Cost Factors for Simulants

Simulants are incredibly affordable. A high-quality CZ ring might cost $50-$100, while Moissanite could range from $300-$800. Their low price makes them attractive for those on tight budgets.

Cost Factors for Lab-Grown Diamonds

Lab-grown diamonds are pricier than simulants but still cheaper than natural diamonds. You might save 30-40% compared to a mined diamond of similar quality.

Resale Value Considerations

Here’s the kicker: neither simulants nor lab-grown diamonds hold much resale value. Natural diamonds retain some worth, but the market for man-made stones is still evolving.

Investment Potential

If you’re looking for an investment piece, stick with natural diamonds. Simulants and lab-grown stones are better suited for personal enjoyment rather than financial gain.

Pros and Cons of Simulated Diamonds

Advantages

  • Affordability: Perfect for budget-conscious buyers.
  • Availability: Widely accessible in stores and online.
  • No Mining Required: Ethical choice for eco-conscious consumers.

Disadvantages

  • Durability Concerns: Softer materials mean shorter lifespans.
  • Different Optical Properties: These may not look as authentic as real diamonds.
  • Low Resale Value: Essentially disposable after purchase.

Pros and Cons of Lab-Grown Diamonds

Advantages

  • Identical to Natural Diamonds: Same composition and durability.
  • Ethical Sourcing: No environmental harm from mining.
  • Lower Cost: More affordable than natural alternatives.

Disadvantages

  • Resale Challenges: Limited secondary market.
  • Market Perception Issues: Some view them as “less valuable.”

Making the Right Choice: Which Option Is Best For You

Choosing between simulants, lab-grown diamonds, and natural diamonds depends on several factors:

  • Budget: How much are you willing to spend?
  • Intended Use: Will this be worn daily or saved for special occasions?
  • Value Priorities: Do you care more about appearance, durability, sustainability, or price?

Ask yourself questions like: Am I okay with a lower resale value? Do I want something that looks exactly like a diamond? Your answers will guide your decision.

Common Misconceptions and Marketing Claims

Misleading Terminology

Terms like “synthetic diamonds” or “cultured diamonds” can confuse buyers. Always clarify what you’re being sold.

Environmental and Ethical Claims

While lab grown diamonds are marketed as eco-friendly, the energy required for production isn’t negligible. Research brands carefully.

Tips for Identifying Misleading Marketing

Look for certifications, ask detailed questions, and avoid vague promises.

How to Identify What You're Buying

  • Always check for certifications from reputable labs like GIA or IGI.
  • Use a diamond tester or observe how the stone reacts to light and water.
  • Be wary of overly cheap prices or retailers who can’t provide proper documentation.

Conclusion

To recap, simulated diamonds are imitations, while lab-grown diamonds are the real deal just made in a lab. Understanding these distinctions empowers you to make informed choices. Whether you prioritize affordability, ethics, or longevity, there’s an option for everyone. Ultimately, the best choice is the one that aligns with your priorities and values.

Previous Post Next Post